But before we can begin such discussions, a few preliminary points need to be addressed. This insures optimal utilization of the information but of course provides no incentive for investment in research. Among the intangible objects of property rights are names, trademarks, good will of a company, jobs, access to markets and intellectual and artistic products such as books, symphonic and technical process. Intellectual property dynamics in the global knowledge economy 105 introduction there are a number of traditional justifications for intellectual property rights. Traditional rights mainly elaborated by locke and jefferson are called negative rights these rights are right to life, liberty, property and the pursuit of happiness. We begin this chapter on property rights with libecaps 1989 contracting for property rights,in which libecap provides substantive research concerning the way property rights are formed.
Theories of property rights and chinas reforms sciencedirect. Intellectual property and management theories ellie okada, ph. Property theory, metaphors and the continuum of land rights. Such institutions critically affect decision making regarding resource use and hence, affect economic behavior and performance. Two views of ethics robert mcgee barry university introduction most discussions of political philosophy revolve around the relationship between the individual and the state or the individual and the masses. This article explores the nature of property rights systems, their evolution, and their effect on resource allocation. Law and economics scholars are pleased to eschew altogether any special meaning for property, viewing it as an aggregation of legal rights or, in the common. When a person is deprived of what he has created he becomes. Property rights and the theory of contracts mises institute. Theories of property rights and asset ownership have gained wider intellectual currency in the economics discipline in recent years, following the seminal works of. Property rights in and of themselves give people a certain status and recognition in society. Property rights theory and the empirical literature that tests it in the context of strategic alliances generates two main insights. Paul torremans, intellectual property and human rights, kluwer law international, 2008 8.
Coase 1960 initiated a flurry of property rights research that perhaps reached its peak with alchian and demsetz 1973. Public property and property rights theory abstract the state has a dominant position in property rights. Theory and implications for development policy gershon feder and david feeny this article explores the nature of property rights systems, their evolution, and their effect on resource allocation. As a general theory of contractual choice, property rights theory bridges the differences between agency and transaction costs theories by.
The theories of intellectual property philosophy essay. They allow creators, or owners, of patents, trademarks or ed works to benefit from their own work or investment in a creation. The theory of natural law is derived from the principle that one owns that which one creates by ones own intellectual effort and labour. Property theories and metaphors there are two main schools of thought on how to address land tenure and property rights. For example, traditional knowledge protection may be better justified by theories of distributive justice.
I am indebted in this section of the book to this excellent paper, particularly. This attribute has four broad components and is often referred to as a. Property rights theory has common antecedents with contractual theories of the firm such as transaction costs and agency theories, and is yet distinct from these theories. The problem of optimal allocation of property rights di. This part will question whether this restriction is fairly justified. Law five theories of property rights lecture 6 five. Property theories have been labelled evolutionary theories of property. Property rights refer to a social concept that includes the principle of ownership and recognizes the use of the owned property. Pdf property rights theory, transaction costs theory, and. Property rights have certain characteristics which are not possessed by other kinds of rights and duties. This limits the interest theorys rights, but this does not solve the will theorys problems with inalienable rights, etc.
This research book provides a clear structure to and balanced overview of the property rights literature. It we scan these rights we shall find that they impose some restrictions upon the activities and power of the state authority. Thebasic assumption of the theory is, that an efficient result can be achievedregardless of who is the owner of a resource but not without an owner or with more legal owners. By owning property, it gives the owner an independence from governmental power. In the context of intellectual property, it is generally thought that, lawmakers must strike an optimal balance between, on one hand, the individual rights of the. In a free enterprise economy, inventive activity is supported by using the invention to create property. Many of us are surprised when we meet someone with a different point of view about property rights. These rights are outlined in article 27 of the universal declaration of human rights, which provides. Property and ownership stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. A critical issue in urban economic development international housing coalition and urban institute executive summary background. Theories of human rights in relation to understandings of. The first and most popular of the four employs the familiar utilitarian guideline that lawmakers must put emphasis on maximization of net social welfare while shaping property rights. So, it may take to conclude that intellectual property rights are natural rights.
According to the property rights theory, the primary function of property rights is that of guiding incentives to achieve a greater internalization of externalities. We illustrate fundamental theoretical principles derived from these three theories by analyzing the business case of oil field unitization. The theory of property rights is a subsection of new institutional economics and studies the action and disposal rights for goods. Possible hybrid theories an interest theory with a single interest the only sufficient reason for rights is the interest of freedom. The theory states that the relationship between property and democracy is important because the democracy allows a property owner the independence and equality they require from the government. A libertarian, naturalrights, propertyrights theory must therefore reconstitute contract law on the proper titletransfer basis. It is true that temporal limitation is applicable to intellectual property. In modern contract theory, the theory of the firm is often identified with the property rights approach that was developed by sanford j. Alternative perspectives on rights to intellectual property, 71 j. Property rights theory, transaction costs theory, and agency theory. This essay canvasses those theories, evaluates them, and considers the roles they do and ought to play in lawmaking. Justificatory theories for intellectual property viewed. This paper discusses the concept of property rights in an interdisciplinary perspective.
Steven d anderman, interface between intellectual property rights and competition policy, cambridge university press, 2007. Actually goods without private property like the open access common. Toward a theory of property rights harold demsetz the. Economists usually take the bundle of property rights as a datum and ask for an explanation of the forces determining the price and the number of units of a good to which these rights attach. The fact that the exclusive right permits the creator to forbid the others from using his work is the main source of conflict. In order to transfer property, one must have title to convey to others.
Ethics 441, 44142 2007 proposing an efficiency approach for understanding and evaluating intellectual property rights. The book will be of particular interest to students seeking an accessible introduction to contemporary theories of property, but even specialists will benefit from the books lucid descriptions of contemporary debates. The problem is that natural right theory doesnt cope with the temporal limitation of intellectual property rights. Libecaps research book is a synthesis of theory and history, which emphasizes the complexities of property rights formation. Intellectual property rights are relations between individuals, as is the case with other property rights. Libecaps research book is a synthesis of theory and history, which emphasizes the complexities of. With this background in place, the implications of the theory for questions about property rights and taxation are explored. Property rights theory, transaction costs theory, and agency.
To learn, understand and analyse the laws and relations relating to intellectual property rights in india along with the glimpse of international practices. Property rights can be viewed as an attribute of an economic good. This chapter surveys some theories of the optimal allocation of property rights. A primer we all have opinions about property rights. Property rights school and the process of social change, s. Intellectual property is most of the time limited in time as to the protection accorded by law. Property rights are an important class of institutional arrangement. In general, property as a social institution implies a system of relations between individuals. Labour theory lockes theory property right is a natural right. Ownership, property rights, and economic performance, by david kotz 1 1. Pdf agency and property rights theories in agricultural. Five theories of property rights thesis of this presentationmany environmental policy disputes appear to be about differences in methods, data, assumptions or coefficientsbut they are actually disputes about competing theories of property rights five competing theories. Property rights, universal publishing house, 2014 7. The dominant school draws on modernization development theory and a related form of evolutionary thinking.
Questions addressed to the emergence and mix of the components of the bundle of rights are prior to those commonly asked by economists. Section 2 is an overview of critical concepts in property rights, specifically, the notion of bundles of rights, the range of property rights regimes e. Any objective study of gender and property rights s the dismal record of reflect developing countries in providing women with equal rights not only to but to the basic land necessities of life. Evers, toward a reformulation of the law of contracts, journal of libertarian studies 1 winter 1977.
The right of private property was vigorously asserted by the. These may be related to general human rights or to pedagogical theories. Ownership, property rights, and economic performance. It is argued that certain institutional arrangements for. Intellectual property rights are like any other property right. Introduction concept of property visavis intellectual property concept of property and theories of property an overview. Introduction ownership and property have practically the same meaning in english. The concept of property occupies an important place in human life because it is practically impossible to live without the use of material object which constitutes the subject matter of property.
Resources can be owned by and hence be the property of individuals, associations, collectives, or governments. This article explores the nature of property rights systems, their. This paper aims to identify what kind of opportunities we have in incorporating intellectual property ip elements in management theories, as well as in policy issues. Property rights are theoretical sociallyenforced constructs in economics for determining how a resource or economic good is used and owned. Theories of property rights and chinas reforms xiaokai yang abstract. In short, property rights acknowledge that a person or entity can. The roman property laws were as far as possible removed from. Roman philosophers things in patrimony things capable of being taken in private ownership things out of patrimony things which cannot be owned privately natural law theory grotius res nullies nobodys property ownerless, abandoned property is free to be owned pufendorf res communes things owned by no one and subject to. It then shows how a natural law theory of the grounds and content of our moral obligations follows from this understanding of nature, and how a doctrine of natural rights follows in turn from the theory of natural law. Toward a theory of property rights when a transaction is concluded in the marketplace, two bundles of property rights are exchanged. A person has a right to own the creation of his mind in the same manner he owns creation of his labour. Instead, it aims to make the major property theories comprehensible to beginners, without sacrificing accuracy or sophistication. Property rights theory, transaction costs theory, and. Property rights theory and the governance of strategic alliances.
923 774 1084 1553 972 1404 101 974 965 1608 1028 183 912 1132 337 1616 898 1060 1380 18 313 1230 606 776 1107 870 1054 848 1132 768 757 954 834 23 1054 1246 584 260 167 51 1172 353 74 631 665 1394 1056